14.4 Engineering Heat Transfer ended with a fin whose boundary condition turned into a problem about and . A beam is the same bookkeeping one derivative up. Press the tip of a ruler clamped to a desk and it bends; let go and it rings. Both come from one equation of fourth order in , with two end conditions at each end. The static problem was previewed in 5.7 Higher-Order Linear Equations, and the ringing is the standing-wave problem of 9.4 The Wave Equation & Vibrating Strings with a twist: the frequencies are not a harmonic series. We derive both, solve them exactly, build a finite-difference solver and check it, and end on a lift-loaded wing spar.
Transcript
- A beam is the fin's boundary-condition bookkeeping one derivative up. Bending moment is E I times the curvature y double prime, where E I is Young's modulus times the second moment of area. For a rectangle I is b t cubed over 12, so doubling the thickness makes the beam 8 times stiffer. Slice equilibrium gives E I y four primes equals q, and the slice's mass adds rho A y t t. Fourth order means four constants, so two conditions at each end. Clamped sets y and slope to zero, pinned sets y and moment, free sets moment and shear, sliding sets slope and shear.
- Take the cantilever with a tip load P. Integrating twice, the tip moves P L cubed over 3 E I: a spring. Under uniform load q it is q L to the fourth over 8 E I. Pinned at both ends, the midspan deflection is 5 q L to the fourth over 384 E I, and clamped at both ends, q L to the fourth over 384 E I. At the same scale the cantilever sags 9.6 times more than the simply supported beam. For a steel ruler, 25 millimetres wide, 3 thick and 0.30 metres long, with E and rho from memory, E I is 11.25. A 1 newton tip load deflects it 0.800 millimetres.
- Separate variables: space gives phi four primes equals beta to the fourth phi, solved by cos, sin, cosh and sinh. The four end conditions have a nonzero solution only when a determinant vanishes. For the cantilever that is cos beta L times cosh beta L equals minus 1. There is no closed form, but bisection gives 1.8751, 4.6941 and 7.8548. The nth mode has n minus 1 interior nodes, and omega is beta L squared times the square root of E I over rho A L to the fourth. For the ruler, the first frequency is 170.77 radians per second, 27.18 hertz.
- A string has omega equal to n c pi over L, a harmonic series: 1, 2, 3. A pinned beam has omega proportional to n squared: 1, 4, 9, 16. For the cantilever the ratios are 1, 6.267, 17.55, 34.39 and 56.84, so a beam's overtones are not harmonics. In plane-wave language omega is the square root of E I over rho A times k squared. The phase speed grows with k, and the group speed is twice the phase speed. The beam is dispersive, and the string is not.
- A grid needs no determinant. Applying the second difference twice gives the five-point stencil, 1, minus 4, 6, minus 4, 1, over h to the fourth. Near an end it reaches outside the beam, so the end conditions supply ghost points. Clamped makes row 1 equal to 7, minus 4, 1. Free gives the last two rows 1, minus 4, 5, minus 2 and 2, minus 4, 2. For the cantilever under uniform load the tip error falls from 1.00 percent to 0.0039 percent, and the first-frequency error from minus 0.837 to minus 0.0033. Each doubling divides the error by 4.00: second order.
- Omega max is about 4 times the square root of E I over rho A, over h squared: at N equal to 80, 25,590 against 4 N squared, 25,600. Explicit leapfrog needs omega max times delta t at most 2, so delta t is at most h squared over twice the square root of E I over rho A. A string's limit is h over c, so halving h halves the string's limit and quarters the beam's. In a pinned-pinned run with N equal to 20, the limit is 1.258 times 10 to the minus 3. At 0.95 of it the solution stays bounded; at 1.05 it grew to 10 to the 106 in 400 steps.
- A wing spar is a cantilever clamped at the root. The half-wing of the light aircraft carries W equal to 6316.5 newtons over s equal to 5.5 metres. The usual first model, from memory, is elliptic lift. Superposing tip loads gives a deflection of W s cubed over E I times 1 eighth minus 4 over 45 pi. With a hypothetical E I of 1.0 times 10 to the 6 and rho A of 15, the tip moves 0.10163 metres, which is 0.7736 of the uniform-load value, because the lift sits nearer the root. The root moment is 14,744 newton metres, against 17,370 for uniform lift, and the first frequency is 4.776 hertz. Flutter, from memory, needs a second mode, and a pure beam cannot show it.
- The beam is a wave problem with the unusual relation omega proportional to k squared. The next lesson, acoustics, covers sound. The syllabus lists the acoustic wave equation from linearised compressible flow, the speed of sound, standing waves in pipes, spherical waves, reflection and transmission, the Doppler effect and a 2D room simulation. There the equation is the ordinary wave equation, derived from the Euler equations rather than from a force balance on a slice.
From bending to
A thin beam of length lies along , and is its small transverse displacement, measured in the direction of the load. Euler-Bernoulli theory assumes that cross-sections stay flat and perpendicular to the bent centreline, that slopes are small, and that the material is linear elastic. Shear deformation and rotary inertia are ignored.
A beam with curvature stretches the outer fibres and shortens the inner ones in proportion to their distance from the centre: strain , stress . The resultant moment is
is the bending stiffness: Young’s modulus times the second moment of area. For a rectangle of width and thickness , , so doubling the thickness makes the beam eight times stiffer.
Now take a slice of width . The shear forces on its faces differ by the load, per unit length, and its moment balance (the load’s own moment is second order) gives . Eliminating,
with the bending moment and the shear force, up to a sign that books choose differently. For motion, Newton’s law for the slice has mass ( density, cross-section area), the load , and the internal force per length:
The homogeneous version is the one in the table of 9.9 Infinite Domains & the Fourier Transform with .
Four kinds of end
A fourth-order equation has four constants, so it needs four conditions, two at each end. Each end pairs a geometric quantity with a force quantity, and exactly one of each pair is given:
| End | Conditions | Physical meaning |
|---|---|---|
| clamped (built in) | a wall: no displacement and no rotation; the wall supplies force and moment | |
| pinned (simply supported) | held in place but free to turn: zero moment | |
| free | nothing touches it: zero moment and zero shear | |
| sliding | in a frictionless slot: slope held at zero, no transverse force |
Some of the sixteen combinations are singular: a pinned-free beam can swing about the pin and a free-free beam can float away, so a static load has no unique answer.
Static deflection
Take the cantilever (clamped at , free at ) with a tip load . Equilibrium of the piece beyond gives the moment , which vanishes at the free end, so . Integrate with and :
So the tip load acts like a spring, stiffness . A uniform load, integrated four times, gives (5.7 Higher-Order Linear Equations). For the simply supported beam, satisfies at both ends, and for clamped-clamped works (Problem 2). The lab’s exact solver, which solves the four end conditions as a system, confirms:
| Beam and load | Peak deflection |
|---|---|
| clamped-free, tip load | , at the tip |
| clamped-free, uniform | , at the tip |
| pinned-pinned, uniform | , midspan |
| pinned-pinned, midspan | |
| clamped-clamped, uniform | , midspan |
Under the same load a cantilever sags times more than a clamped-clamped beam and times more than a simply supported one.
Worked example: a steel ruler. Take mm, mm, m, and (from memory) GPa, kg/m. Then m, N m, kg/m. A N tip load deflects it mm (stiffness N/m), and its own weight, N/m, sags the tip mm.
Free vibration: separation of variables
Set and look for standing waves . Then , so is a constant, which we call :
The sign is forced: multiply by and integrate by parts. For every end type the boundary terms vanish and , the bending energy. A free-free beam has two zero-frequency modes (translation and rotation), where vanishes.
The spatial equation has characteristic polynomial , with roots and (as in 5.7 Higher-Order Linear Equations), so the general solution is
Compared with the string’s there are two extra hyperbolic pieces, like the fin profile. The four end conditions give a homogeneous system, and nonzero solutions exist only when its determinant vanishes: a frequency equation for . This is the Sturm-Liouville problem of 8.2 Eigenvalue Problems & Sturm–Liouville Theory at fourth order.
Pinned-pinned. At , gives and , so . At the same two conditions give , so and : the string’s answer.
Cantilever. Clamping at () leaves . The free end needs :
The determinant is , using and . The frequency equation is
There is no closed form, but bisection works: is huge for , so the roots hug the zeros of , ( against for ). The first three are . The mode shape is with (); the th mode has interior nodes, which the lab counts.
Every other pair of ends is the same game with a different determinant:
| Ends | (first three) | |
|---|---|---|
| clamped-free (cantilever) | ||
| pinned-pinned | ||
| clamped-pinned | ||
| clamped-clamped, or free-free |
Clamped-clamped and free-free share a frequency equation () but not shapes. The frequency is , so the ruler’s first cantilever frequency is rad/s, Hz; pinned at both ends over the same span it would ring at Hz.
Orthogonality, and why a beam is not a string
Let and be modes with . Multiply by , subtract the same with and swapped, and recognise a total derivative:
The bracket vanishes because at every end each of the four products contains a factor that the end condition sets to zero (check it for all four end types). So : the modes are orthogonal, like the normal modes of 14.1 Coupled Oscillators & Normal Modes, and a general motion is a sum of modes with . The lab evaluates numerically: for and about for the others.
The big difference is the spectrum. A string has , a harmonic series. A pinned beam has : . For the cantilever , so a beam’s overtones are not harmonics. In plane-wave language, : the phase speed grows with and the group speed is , as in 9.9 Infinite Domains & the Fourier Transform. The beam is dispersive; the string is not.
A numerical beam solver
The exact approach needs a determinant per pair of ends and fails for variable . A grid does not care. Use nodes , . Applying the second difference twice,
That stencil reaches two nodes each way, so near an end it needs ghost points outside the beam, and the end conditions supply them. For the cantilever with unknowns :
- Clamped at : drops out, and with a central difference sets . Row is .
- Free at : zero moment gives , and zero shear . Row becomes and row becomes .
- Every other row is .
Call this matrix and set . The static problem is ; the vibration problem is with , the eigenproblem of from 14.1 Coupled Oscillators & Normal Modes. The end rows make non-symmetric, yet its eigenvalues came out real. A point load enters as at its node, or at a free end (half a cell).
For the cantilever in units (checked against an independent script), the tip deflection under uniform load and the first frequency, whose exact values are and :
| tip deflection | error | error | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Each doubling of cuts the error by for the deflection and to for the frequency: second order, as the stencil promised. Higher modes are harder: at the errors of are , , , , (fewer points per bend).
Finite elements (10.13 Introduction to Finite Elements) would need slope-continuous shape functions, since the beam energy is ; from memory, the standard fix is Hermite cubic elements. I did not implement them.
The wing as a cantilever
A wing spar carries the lift of its half-wing to the fuselage: a cantilever clamped at the root with a distributed lift. Use the light aircraft of 12.1 Airfoils, Circulation & Lift: N over an m span, so one half-wing carries N over m. Spanwise lift is not uniform. The usual first model (from memory, lifting-line theory, not derived in this course) is elliptic: , measured from the root, with area , so N/m.
The tip deflection needs no new solver. A point load at bends the beam to at with slope , and the part beyond is straight, so the tip moves . Superpose over the load, with :
which is . Spread uniformly the same lift gives , so the elliptic tip moves only of that: the lift sits nearer the root. The root moment is N m, against N m.
Take hypothetical constant values (a real spar tapers): N m, kg/m. At g the tip deflects m, of the span, and the frequencies are , and Hz. At g the tip is at m, of the span. Finite differences with give Hz; the lab’s gives Hz and a tip about low, since the elliptic load’s square-root end is less smooth. The model ignores torsion and taper.
Flutter, a glimpse, entirely from memory. Lift on a bending wing depends on its deflection and velocity, so in modal form and the eigenvalues move with airspeed . Flutter is the speed at which a pair crosses into the right half-plane, the picture of 12.6 Lateral-Directional Modes. As I remember it, it needs a second mode, usually torsion; a pure beam cannot show it.
Two more glimpses
Both from memory, not derived. Timoshenko theory adds shear deformation and rotary inertia, lowering the frequencies of short thick beams; it is negligible for the ruler (). Euler buckling: a cantilever under axial compression buckles at , which is N for the ruler.
The lab
Three experiments:
- Static, default (clamped-free, uniform, ): peak , finite differences , largest nodal error of the peak ( at ). A tip point load gives ; pinned-pinned ; clamped-clamped . Pinned-free and free-free are singular, and the lab says so.
- Modes, clamped-free, : , , two interior nodes. At the numerical ; for to the error is .
- Wing, defaults: tip m (closed form and exact solver), m at , uniform comparison m; at g, m.
The exercise: a beam solver
The playgrounds find the cantilever roots by bisection and tabulate the wing. The exercise builds the finite-difference matrix, solves the static problem, and extracts frequencies from with np.linalg.eigvals.
Concept checks
Problems
For the steel ruler ( N m, m) find the tip force that gives a mm deflection.
Show worked solution
N/m, so N.
Check that solves with at both ends, and find the midspan deflection.
Show worked solution
Expand: . Only survives four derivatives, giving , so . The factor gives , and the factor gives . At : , one forty-eighth of the cantilever’s .
For elliptic lift with total , find the bending moment at the root, , and compare it with a uniform load of the same . Evaluate for N and m.
Show worked solution
With : . So . Uniform: . The ratio is . Numerically N m against N m.
What comes next
The beam is a wave problem with the unusual relation . The next lesson, 14.6 Acoustics & Wave Propagation, covers sound; the syllabus lists the acoustic wave equation from linearised compressible flow, the speed of sound, standing waves in pipes, spherical waves, reflection and transmission, the Doppler effect and a 2D room simulation. There the equation is the ordinary wave equation of 9.4 The Wave Equation & Vibrating Strings, derived from the Euler equations of 11.3 Momentum: Pressure & the Euler Equations rather than from a force balance on a slice.
Key Takeaways
- Moment-curvature plus slice equilibrium gives and ; for a rectangle.
- Two end conditions per end: clamped (), pinned (), free (), sliding ().
- Static tips: , ; simply supported midspan ; clamped-clamped .
- Separation gives ; the cantilever equation has , and .
- Modes are orthogonal, but : a beam is dispersive and its overtones are not harmonics.
- The 5-point stencil with ghost-point end rows is second order, and its explicit time step must shrink like .
- Elliptic lift gives the half-wing tip deflection , of the uniform-load value.