Last lesson’s laminar layer had a short life. On the light wing (a m chord at m/s, ) the local Reynolds number reaches at m, where a smooth plate’s layer starts to break down (from memory). Behind that point the Blasius profile is gone: the layer becomes turbulent, a churning sheet that mixes fast outer air down to the wall, rubs harder, and holds on longer against an adverse pressure gradient. This lesson asks why it forms, why averaging the equations leaves an unknown, where its energy goes, and why no simulator you will write can resolve it.
Tools: 11.8 Boundary Layers, 11.6 Vorticity Dynamics & Circulation, 11.5 Non-dimensionalization & the Reynolds Number and 7.10 Chaos & the Lorenz System.
Transcript
- Last lesson ended on a promise: the laminar layer is only a lower bound. At Reynolds x of 5 times ten to the fifth, just 0.1461 metres back, it breaks down. The wing's Reynolds number is 5.135 times ten to the sixth, so the chord runs far past that point. Small waves grow, turn three-dimensional, and burst into turbulent spots that merge into one churning sheet.
- Turbulence is chaotic: two flows that start a hair apart soon differ completely. So we predict statistics, not instants. Split every quantity into a mean and a fluctuation, u equals u bar plus u prime. By construction the average of u prime is zero. But a product of fluctuations need not average out: u prime v prime is not zero in general.
- Average the momentum equation and the quadratic term leaves a stress behind: minus rho u prime v prime, momentum carried across the layer by eddies. It is positive, because eddies carry fast air down toward the wall. So a layer turbulent from the leading edge rubs 15.46 newtons per metre, against the laminar 2.693. But the new unknown has its own equation, with triple products, and those have fourth-order ones, forever. That is the closure problem.
- Where does the energy go? The mean shear feeds the largest eddies, the size of the layer. They stretch smaller eddies, by 11.6's vortex stretching, and those stretch smaller ones: Richardson's cascade. Epsilon, the energy per unit mass per second, passes through every scale at the same rate, about u cubed over ell, and ends as heat only where the eddies' own Reynolds number is about one. In two dimensions nothing stretches vorticity.
- Kolmogorov, in 1941: small eddies forget how they were made. In the inertial range the spectrum depends only on epsilon and k, and dimensional analysis forces E of k equals C epsilon to the two thirds, k to the minus five thirds. The synthetic field's FFT fits minus 1.676, against minus 1.667. Honest status: a hypothesis plus dimensional analysis, not a theorem.
- Now the wing's turbulent layer. Delta is 25.25 millimetres. The friction coefficient, 2.693 times ten to the minus three, gives u tau of 1.835 metres per second, and epsilon equals u tau cubed over delta: 244.6 watts per kilogram. The Kolmogorov length is 59.7 micrometres, and delta over eta is 423.
- To simulate directly, the grid must reach eta, so the point count is Reynolds number to the nine fourths. For the wing that is 1.25 times ten to the fifteen. Counting only the turbulent layer's volume still gives 3.55 times ten to the eleven points, 2.12 times ten to the fourth times a 256 cubed grid. Backwards, a 128 grid reaches only Reynolds number 645.
- So we model. RANS solves only the mean flow and models the Reynolds stress with an eddy viscosity. The k-epsilon model builds it from k squared over epsilon, with a constant, 0.09, fitted to simple flows. LES resolves the big eddies and models the small: Smagorinsky's viscosity. A filter at k c equals 16 keeps 79.1 percent of the energy but 10.4 percent of the dissipation. Both are tuned models, poor where wings get interesting.
- Your own solver models turbulence too, by accident. Semi-Lagrangian advection interpolates, which averages, and that adds a numerical viscosity, u delta x times one minus C over two. A sine wave at N equals 64 decays at 2.4834 measured, 2.4674 predicted. It is an uncontrolled, implicit subgrid model.
- No grid we can afford holds the wing's eddies. So the solver must at least get right what it cannot fudge: keeping the air incompressible on a grid. Next, 11.10: split the step, then enforce divergence zero with a pressure projection.
Transition: why a laminar layer breaks down
Blasius is an exact solution, but an exact solution can be unstable. That is 7.7 Nonlinear Systems & Linearization applied to a PDE: linearize about the laminar profile, look for modes , and check the sign of the real part of . On a flat plate, wavy disturbances (Tollmien–Schlichting waves, from memory) grow once passes a critical value, turn three-dimensional, and break into turbulent spots that spread and merge. 11.8’s is typical in a quiet stream; roughness, noise and pressure gradients move it far. Accelerating flow delays it, which is how natural-laminar-flow airfoils keep long laminar runs (from memory).
The turbulent state is chaotic (7.10 Chaos & the Lorenz System): deterministic, but two flows that start a hair apart soon differ completely. Lorenz had three variables; by the count below, the wing’s layer has hundreds of billions. The instantaneous velocity is unpredictable; its statistics (means, variances, spectra) are reproducible, and engineering needs nothing else.
Reynolds decomposition and averaging
Split every quantity into a mean and a fluctuation:
The bar is an average over a time long compared with the eddies but short compared with changes in the mean flow. Four rules follow:
- , by construction.
- .
- : averaging commutes with derivatives.
- in general: a product of fluctuations need not average out.
So averaging a linear term puts a bar on it, while a product gives
Reynolds stresses and the closure problem
With continuity, the advection term is , so 2D -momentum reads
Averaging with the rules above:
In a thin layer 11.8’s scaling keeps only the -derivative of the extra terms, and the mean boundary-layer equation becomes
The fluctuations act on the mean flow like an extra shear stress, the Reynolds stress : momentum carried across the layer by eddies.
Why it is positive, and why the wall rubs harder. In the layer grows with . A parcel moved down () comes from faster air, so it arrives faster than its new neighbours (). A parcel moving up () carries slow air into a fast region (). Either way , so : momentum flows toward the wall far faster than viscosity alone carries it. The mean profile fills out and the wall gradient steepens, and so does . A from-memory turbulent-plate correlation, , puts the light wing’s two-face friction at N/m if turbulent from the leading edge, against 11.8’s laminar N/m (the cost panel prints both); the real wing, laminar for its first , sits between, near the top. The same fast near-wall air is why the layer holds on longer: it has more momentum to spend climbing an adverse gradient (11.8’s golf-ball argument).
The closure problem. Unknowns: , , and the new (in 3D, six Reynolds stresses). Equations: continuity and momentum, one short (six in 3D). An equation for , derived from Navier–Stokes, contains triple products such as , whose equations contain fourth-order products, forever. The cause fits in one line: average over noisy runs,
and the mean’s equation needs the variance. Every turbulence model is a choice of where to cut this chain and what to put there; none follows from Navier–Stokes alone.
The energy cascade
The mean shear feeds the largest eddies, the size of the layer. Their Reynolds number is large, so viscosity barely touches them. Instead they strain smaller eddies, by 11.6’s mechanism: a vortex tube stretched along its axis gets thinner and, with its circulation conserved (Kelvin), spins faster. Energy moves into smaller, faster eddies, which stretch smaller ones still: Richardson’s 1922 picture (from memory) of big whirls feeding little whirls. It turns into heat only at scales whose own Reynolds number is about .
Call the energy fed in per unit mass per second (W/kg m/s). In a steady state the same passes through every scale and is dissipated at the bottom, and it is set at the top:
(an eddy hands on its energy in one turnover time ). Lower the viscosity and the dissipation does not drop; the cascade just runs to smaller scales. That is an experimental fact, not a theorem.
The shell model below is a toy: one complex number per octave of wavenumbers , coupled to its neighbours by quadratic terms that conserve energy as Navier–Stokes’ advection term does (the Sabra model; its form is from memory). Energy is forced into shell and removed by . The right panel plots the time-averaged flux through shell (the rate nonlinearity carries energy past it) over the dissipation rate. In test runs at it sits at over the first ten shells, then drops to zero where viscosity takes over, at the printed . That flat line is the cascade. From to the flat stretch lengthens while the measured stays between about and .
Kolmogorov’s −5/3 and the smallest scales
Kolmogorov proposed in 1941 (from memory) that eddies much smaller than forget how they were made: their statistics depend only on and , and in the inertial range, well above the viscous scales, on alone.
The spectrum by dimensional analysis. is energy per unit mass per unit wavenumber (), units m/s. In the inertial range it depends only on (m/s) and (1/m). Try , the 11.5 method:
with measured (from memory). Its status: a hypothesis plus dimensional analysis, not a theorem from Navier–Stokes. It agrees well with wind-tunnel, jet and atmospheric data; small departures (intermittency, because small-scale activity is patchy) show up in higher statistics. The shell model shows one: its fitted slope of lands between about and in test runs, against Kolmogorov’s (each shell holds a band of width about , so and means ). The flux plateau is the robust result; the exponent is a little off, as in real flows.
The Kolmogorov scales. At the bottom, and (m/s) fix one length, one time and one speed:
Their Reynolds number is : viscosity can just smooth them. Combine with :
Worked example: the light wing’s turbulent layer
Assumptions: sea-level air ( m/s); a layer turbulent from the leading edge, with the from-memory correlations and ; largest eddies of size moving at the friction velocity (layer fluctuations are a few , from memory). An order-of-magnitude estimate; lab block A prints:
- , so at the trailing edge mm, nearly eight times the mm laminar layer of 11.8.
- , m/s.
- W/kg.
- m, s, m/s.
- Check: .
The smallest eddies are a twentieth of a millimetre across and live a quarter of a millisecond; nearer the wall they are smaller still (the wall unit is m).
The field is synthetic: random phases with from to a cut-off ; it has the spectrum but no coherent vortices, a test signal rather than turbulence. Its FFT spectrum fits at (prescribed ). Past , leaves the grid.
The cost of resolving everything: DNS, LES, RANS
Direct numerical simulation (DNS) uses no model, so the grid spacing must reach while the box holds the largest eddies, : per direction points; in 3D,
A step must not carry an -sized eddy past its own size, , over a run of a few : steps, work. Doubling the speed multiplies the grid by and the work by .
For the light wing (lab block B):
- Textbook: points, work.
- Sharper: turbulent volume over (both faces, mm thick, one metre of span): points, times a grid, and steps per chord crossing, still ignoring the finer wall region.
- Backwards: cells per side reach only if , so : for Stam’s , for . The wing is at .
RANS (Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes) solves only the mean-flow equations and models , usually with Boussinesq’s eddy viscosity , where belongs to the flow, not the fluid. The k–ε model builds from the turbulent kinetic energy (m/s) and (m/s); the only viscosity they make is
with and each obeying a transport PDE whose terms are modelled, constants fitted to simple flows. It is poor exactly where a wing gets interesting: strong adverse gradients and separation. Aerodynamic codes favour other, also tuned, models (Spalart–Allmaras, k–ω SST, from memory). RANS is cheap because the grid resolves only the smooth mean profile.
LES (large-eddy simulation) resolves the energy-containing eddies and models the small ones. In the field sim a filter at keeps of the energy but of the dissipation , so the model must remove about of the cascade’s flux at the grid scale. Smagorinsky’s eddy viscosity uses the grid spacing and the resolved strain rate (1/s); the only viscosity they make is
It too is a model: it drains energy wherever there is shear, laminar regions and walls included, and must be damped there (damping functions or a dynamic procedure, from memory). An outer-layer LES of the wing with cells of needs points (lab block B), laptop-sized; the wall region’s cost grows almost like (from memory).
Computing it
Block C’s measured rate is above the prediction because is the leading term of a Taylor series in .
Spectra from data. A hot-wire in the wing’s layer records ; frozen eddies carried past give (Taylor’s hypothesis, from memory). For a sampled periodic signal , , the discrete Fourier transform (NumPy’s rfft divided by ) is the amplitude at wavenumber . For real , is the conjugate of , so the energy at together is , and Parseval reads . The exercise’s signal has amplitudes , so exactly up to , then falls exponentially: a known answer.
Graded: , Parseval (), the slope over , and the warning: over the same data give . Measured data do not mark their inertial range; you choose it, and the answer depends on the choice.
Concept checks
Problems
Using only (m/s) and (m/s), find the unique length, time and speed. Show that their Reynolds number is and that when . Then show that .
Show worked solution
Length : m: , s: , so . Time: , , so . Speed: . Then . With : . And , so . For the wing’s layer, : the smallest eddies turn over times faster than the largest.
At a point in a shear layer, suppose and with . Find , , and (average over a period), and say which way momentum is carried.
Show worked solution
, , , . , so . Upward motion comes with slow air: the Reynolds stress carries -momentum downward, toward a wall below: the fast-air-down mechanism in its simplest form.
A cube of side has largest eddies of size and speed . Show that resolving takes points and, with over a time , point-updates. By what factors do both grow if the wing flies at m/s instead of ? What can a grid hold?
Show worked solution
per direction, cubed: . Steps: ; product . Doubling doubles : points , work . A grid holds , under a thousandth of the wing’s .
Key Takeaways
- Past a critical small waves in a laminar layer grow, break into spots, and the layer turns turbulent: near m on the light wing (, from memory).
- Turbulence is deterministic chaos; we predict statistics, and with averages of products of fluctuations survive.
- Averaging Navier–Stokes adds the Reynolds stress , positive because eddies carry fast air down: more friction ( against N/m for the wing), later separation. Its equation needs higher moments: the closure problem.
- Vortex stretching cascades energy to small scales at a rate independent of ; the shell model shows the constant flux. 2D flow has no forward energy cascade.
- Kolmogorov’s is a hypothesis plus dimensional analysis, not a theorem. , ; in the wing’s layer m.
- DNS needs points and work: points for the wing’s layer, while a grid holds . RANS (k–ε) and LES (Smagorinsky) are tuned models.
- Semi-Lagrangian interpolation is a numerical viscosity : an implicit, uncontrolled subgrid model.
- Next, 11.10: no grid we can afford holds the wing’s eddies, so the solver we build must at least get right the one thing it cannot fudge, keeping the air incompressible on a grid. 11.10 splits Navier–Stokes into steps and enforces with a pressure projection.